Spermicide May Actually Do More Harm Than Good
By Adam Glickman
Years ago it was thought that the
spermicide Nonoxynol-9 that was added to condoms and
sexual lubricants would help prevent both unwanted
pregnancies and the transmission of sexually
transmitted diseases. After a decade of research it
appears that while Nonoxynol-9 is fairly effecting
at killing sperm, it is not effective in fighting
the spread of STD's, including HIV. In fact, it may
actually do more harm than good.
The widely used spermicide
Nonoxynol-9, long recommended as a way to stop the
spread of AIDS, may actually increase the risk of
catching the virus, at least among women who use it
frequently, according to the surprising findings of
a large study.
As a result, health officials said
condoms used solely to prevent disease should not be
coated with Nonoxynol-9, although a condom with the
spermicide is certainly safer than no condom at all.
And they said the spermicide should also not be used
for birth control by anyone at high risk of catching
HIV.
Nonoxynol-9 is widely used around
the world for contraception, and about one-third of
lubricated condoms sold in the United States are
covered with it. Nonoxynol-9 is a detergent
formulated to kill sperm, but in the test tube it
also wipes out HIV, and many have long assumed it
helps protect people from the virus.
However, a study on prostitutes
released at the 13th International AIDS Conference
(1999) showed just the opposite: Women using a
nonoxynol-9 gel increased their risk of contracting
HIV rather than lowering it.
"It is an understatement to
say that we were extremely disappointed," said
Dr. Lut Van Damme of the Institute of Tropical
Medicine in Antwerp, the study's director.
The researchers now assume that
Nonoxynol-9, or N-9, increases the risk by
irritating the vaginal lining, causing tears that
give the virus a way to enter the body.
Bottom Line: Unless you are using
Nonoxynol-9 exclusively for the prevention of
pregnancy and you are certain that you are not
allergic or irritated by N-9, then we suggestion
that you do not use condoms or lubricants that
contain spermicide/Nonoxynol-9.
For more information, or to
purchase condoms with or without spermicide, visit Condomania.com.
Copyright 2002-2004 Condomania.
Reprinted with permission. All rights reserved.